You know that rush when you think the worst is over. The controversy’s done, and the fandom’s moved on. But then one random scroll changes everything? That’s exactly how it felt when “Under Fifteen” (Under15) K-pop survival show popped back into our feeds, making its way back through KBS Japan.
For months, it was the canceled program we thought we’d buried. Then, like an unwelcome déjà vu, it reappeared… this time wearing a new name, “Star Is Born,” and aiming for a different audience.
So, how was it possible? How did they manage to find a back door and insist on returning despite all the controversy? Join the discussion below.
“Under15” K-pop Survival Show: The Japan Comeback That Almost Happened
If you were around during the first “Under Fifteen” storm, you probably remember how fast it escalated.
The “Under Fifteen” (Under15) K-pop survival show was one of the most heavily criticized projects in recent idol industry history. Produced by CReA Studio, its concept centered entirely on debuting a girl group made up of trainees aged 15 and younger — some reportedly as young as eight.
After its planned Korean broadcast was scrapped by MBN amid accusations of sexualizing minors and exploiting young contestants, the project seemed dead.
Therefore, when TenAsia broke the news in early August that the show had resurfaced under a different title and would premiere on KBS Japan on August 11, it felt like the past year’s fight hadn’t mattered.
Teasers were running on YouTube, and for a moment, it seemed like the producers had found a back door.
Why Japan — and Why Now?
For casual viewers, the choice of Japan might sound like a simple distribution decision. But for fans who’ve been following every twist, it carried multiple layers of sensitivity.
Japan is one of the largest overseas markets for K-pop, but it also has its own idol industry history, including controversies over how young performers are marketed.
Moving “Under Fifteen” there, especially right after it was rejected in Korea, made us all wonder:
Did they really think shifting it to a more lenient market would erase everything fans fought for here? And of all places, Japan — a market long known for being more permissive toward underage performers — makes the whole move feel even harder to accept.
And then there was the timing. The premiere was slated just days before Korea’s Liberation Day (August 15), a national holiday marking independence from Japan in 1945.
To many, the idea of airing a highly criticized Korean program for a Japanese audience so close to this date felt careless…or worse, provocative.
Public Broadcaster, Private Loophole
Adding fuel to the outrage was the involvement of KBS Japan, a subsidiary in which Korea’s public broadcaster KBS holds a shareholder stake.
KBS eventually clarified that KBS Japan operates as an independent corporation, making its own programming decisions.
But that explanation did little to calm criticism.
For many viewers, that link alone was enough to spark questions about how a taxpayer-funded broadcaster could still be tied, even indirectly, to a program accused of exploiting minors.
The backlash was swift. On August 9 KST, KBS announced the program would be removed from KBS Japan’s lineup, citing public opinion in both Korea and abroad.
The Japan Broadcast of “Under15” K-pop Show: Fans Felt Betrayed — Again
For global fans and civic advocates who had already fought to stop the “Under Fifteen” (Under15) once, the decision to air the K-pop survival show again felt like reopening an old wound. And it was even worse when they decided to do it in Japan.
One longtime fan on X summed it up: “The exploitation of Japanese women and girls is so sick.. like wdym they’re reviving that ‘Under15’ show in Japan???”
This went far beyond a single survival show. It struck a nerve with fans who’ve seen the same pattern before — an industry pulling the plug in one market, only to quietly test the waters in another, as if the outcry never happened.
The Japan plan seemed to confirm that the core issues — child sexualization, industry ethics, and safeguarding minors — were still being sidestepped rather than addressed.
“Under15” K-pop Survival Show Japan Canceled Again: The Global Ethics Question
For years, K-pop has built its image as a global cultural leader. Yet, moments like this push fans to ask: what does that leadership actually look like?
If “Under Fifteen” (Under15) K-pop survival show couldn’t meet the ethical standards in its own home country, does it make sense for it to quietly appear somewhere else?
And then there’s the accountability gap — that space where companies can point to corporate structures and say, “We’re different companies,” while still benefiting from the outcome.
In a time when K-pop content can reach fans anywhere within hours, ethical responsibility can’t have borders.
What This Means for Fans and the Industry
If you love survival shows, this might feel complicated. You tune in for the music, the growth arcs, the thrill of seeing a dream come true.
However, it’s wtill worth asking yourself:
- Should there be clearer age limits for trainees who join these programs?
- Do you want more transparency from broadcasters about canceled projects?
- Should K-pop have one global standard for protecting minors, no matter the market?
Your opinions matter more than you think. Industry decisions are shaped not just in boardrooms but in the noise — or silence — from the fandom.
“Under15” Japan Broadcast Attempt: A Near-Miss That Says a Lot
Yes, the Japan broadcast of “Under Fifteen” (Under15) never happened, but the fact it got that far says plenty. It showed how easily a controversial project can resurface with a different title and a new target audience. It reminded fans that even “canceled” doesn’t always mean over.
For some, it’s another case closed, while others, it may proof that the conversation around minors in K-pop is still far from settled. But for all of us in this community, it’s a reminder to always stay informed, speak up, and keep the pressure on when the industry crosses lines.
Because in a fandom this connected, even a quiet back door can’t stay hidden for long — and the people watching it most closely are often the ones who care the most.
Don’t you think so too? Please share your thoughts in the comments.
Join us on Kpoppost’s Instagram, Threads, Facebook, X, Telegram channel, WhatsApp Channel and Discord server for discussions. And follow Kpoppost’s Google News for more Korean entertainment news and updates.
